American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
Buckeye Association of School Administrators
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Livingstone, Fred (9528)
, Counsel of Record
Mottley, James (55164)
Stelter, Judson (84295)
|
|
Buckeye State Sheriffs' Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Byron, Stephen (55657)
, Counsel of Record
Gotherman, John (504)
Schaltenbrand, Rebecca (64817)
Smith, Stephen (1344)
|
|
Coalition on Homelessness & Housing in Ohio
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Bergeron, Pierre (71402)
, Counsel of Record
Amrine, Thomas (72060)
|
|
Communications Workers of America District 4
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
Corporation for Ohio Appalachian Development
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Bergeron, Pierre (71402)
, Counsel of Record
Amrine, Thomas (72060)
|
|
County Commissioners Association of Ohio
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Byron, Stephen (55657)
, Counsel of Record
Gotherman, John (504)
Schaltenbrand, Rebecca (64817)
Smith, Stephen (1344)
|
|
Fraternal Order of Police of Ohio, Incorporated
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
Multistate Tax Commission
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Laskin, Sheldon (0)
, Counsel of Record
Sicilian, Shirley (0)
|
|
Ohio AFL-CIO
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
Ohio Association of Free Clinics
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Bergeron, Pierre (71402)
, Counsel of Record
Amrine, Thomas (72060)
|
|
Ohio Association of Professional Firefighters
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
Ohio Association of Public School Employees (OAPSE)/AFSCME L
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
Ohio Association of School Business Officials
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Livingstone, Fred (9528)
, Counsel of Record
Mottley, James (55164)
Stelter, Judson (84295)
|
|
Ohio Business Roundtable
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Farrin, Richard (22850)
, Counsel of Record
Trafford, Kathleen (21753)
Zaino, Thomas (41945)
|
|
Ohio Chemistry Technology Council
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Tunnell, Kurtis (38569)
, Counsel of Record
Engel, Mark (19486)
Sferra, Anne (30855)
|
|
Ohio Council of Behavioral Health & Family Services Provider
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Bergeron, Pierre (71402)
, Counsel of Record
Amrine, Thomas (72060)
|
|
Ohio Dental Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Tunnell, Kurtis (38569)
, Counsel of Record
Engel, Mark (19486)
Sferra, Anne (30855)
|
|
Ohio Education Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
Ohio Federation of Teachers
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
Ohio Legal Assistance Foundation
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Bergeron, Pierre (71402)
, Counsel of Record
Amrine, Thomas (72060)
|
|
Ohio Manufacturers' Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Tunnell, Kurtis (38569)
, Counsel of Record
Engel, Mark (19486)
Sferra, Anne (30855)
|
|
Ohio Municipal League
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Byron, Stephen (55657)
, Counsel of Record
Gotherman, John (504)
Schaltenbrand, Rebecca (64817)
Smith, Stephen (1344)
|
|
Ohio School Boards Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Livingstone, Fred (9528)
, Counsel of Record
Mottley, James (55164)
Stelter, Judson (84295)
|
|
Ohio Society of Certified Public Accountants
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Tunnell, Kurtis (38569)
, Counsel of Record
Engel, Mark (19486)
Sferra, Anne (30855)
|
|
Ohio State Bar Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Tunnell, Kurtis (38569)
, Counsel of Record
Engel, Mark (19486)
Sferra, Anne (30855)
|
|
Ohio State Medical Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Tunnell, Kurtis (38569)
, Counsel of Record
Engel, Mark (19486)
Sferra, Anne (30855)
|
|
Ohio Township Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Byron, Stephen (55657)
, Counsel of Record
Gotherman, John (504)
Schaltenbrand, Rebecca (64817)
Smith, Stephen (1344)
|
|
Service Employees International Union District 1199
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Walter, Robert (9491)
, Counsel of Record
Melle, James (9493)
|
|
The Buckeye Institute for Public Policy Solutions
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Thompson, Maurice (78548)
, Counsel of Record
Henchman, Joseph (0)
|
|
The Ohio Restaurant Association
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Chappelear, Stephen (12205)
, Counsel of Record
|
|
The Tax Foundation
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Thompson, Maurice (78548)
, Counsel of Record
Henchman, Joseph (0)
|
|
Tyson Sales & Distribution, Inc.
(Amicus Curiae on behalf of Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
deVyver, Kristopher (72633)
, Counsel of Record
Lima, Sara (0)
Sollie, Kyle (0)
|
|
Levin, Richard A.
(Appellant)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Mizer, Benjamin (83089)
, Counsel of Record
Brigner, Julie (66367)
Carney, Stephen (63460)
Cordray, Richard (38034)
Long, Elisabeth (84128)
Pratt, Lawrence (21870)
|
|
Carfagna's Incorporated
(Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Gosnell, Gerhardt (64919)
, Counsel of Record
Brey, Donald (21965)
Saxbe, Charles (21952)
|
|
CFZ Supermarkets, Inc.
(Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Gosnell, Gerhardt (64919)
, Counsel of Record
Brey, Donald (21965)
Saxbe, Charles (21952)
|
|
Ohio Grocers Association
(Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Gosnell, Gerhardt (64919)
, Counsel of Record
Brey, Donald (21965)
Saxbe, Charles (21952)
|
|
Reading Food Services, Inc.
(Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Gosnell, Gerhardt (64919)
, Counsel of Record
Brey, Donald (21965)
Saxbe, Charles (21952)
|
|
The Sanson Company
(Appellee)
| |
Represented by: |
| |
|
Gosnell, Gerhardt (64919)
, Counsel of Record
Brey, Donald (21965)
Saxbe, Charles (21952)
|
|
| Date Filed |
Description |
10/17/08
View
|
Notice of appeal of Richard A. Levin, Ohio Tax Commissioner
|
10/17/08
View
|
Memorandum in support of jurisdiction
|
10/17/08
View
|
Motion for admission pro hac vice of Michael Dominic Meuti
|
|
|
02/04/09: Granted
|
10/17/08
View
|
Jurisdictional memorandum of amicus curiae Ohio Business Roundtable in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Business Roundtable |
|
10/17/08
View
|
Jurisdictional memorandum of amici curiae Ohio Manufacturers' Association et al. in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Chemistry Technology Council |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Dental Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Manufacturers' Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Society of Certified Public Accountants |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio State Bar Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio State Medical Association |
|
| 10/20/08
|
Copy of notice of appeal sent to clerk of court of appeals
|
10/31/08
View
|
Waiver of memorandum in response
| |
Filed by: |
Carfagna's Incorporated |
| |
Filed by: |
CFZ Supermarkets, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Grocers Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Reading Food Services, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
The Sanson Company |
|
02/04/09
View
|
DECISION: Appeal accepted
|
02/04/09
View
|
Order to clerk of court/custodian to certify record
|
| 02/25/09
|
Record
|
| 02/25/09
|
Clerk's notice of filing of record
|
04/03/09
View
|
Notice of appearance of Stephen P. Carney, Elisabeth A. Long, and Julie Brigner
|
04/03/09
 | See Above |
|
And notice of withdrawal of Michael Dominic Meuti
|
04/03/09
View
|
Brief of amici curiae Ohio Manufacturers' Association et al. in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Chemistry Technology Council |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Dental Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Manufacturers' Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Society of Certified Public Accountants |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio State Bar Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio State Medical Association |
|
04/03/09
View
|
Motion for admission pro hac vice of Sheldon H. Laskin for Multistate Tax Commission
|
View
|
06/03/09: Granted
|
04/03/09
View
|
Motion for admission pro hac vice of Shirley K. Sicilian for Multistate Tax Commission
|
|
|
06/03/09: Granted
|
04/06/09
View
|
Brief of amici curiae Ohio School Boards Association, Buckeye Association of School Administrators, and the Ohio Association of School Business Officials in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Buckeye Association of School Administrators |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Association of School Business Officials |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio School Boards Association |
|
04/06/09
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae Ohio Business Roundtable in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Business Roundtable |
|
04/06/09
View
|
Brief of amici curiae Ohio Legal Assistance Foundation, Coalition on Homelessness & Housing in Ohio, Corporation for Ohio Appalachian Development, Ohio Association of Free Clinics, and Ohio Council of Behavioral Health & Family Services Providers in
| |
Filed by: |
Coalition on Homelessness & Housing in Ohio |
| |
Filed by: |
Corporation for Ohio Appalachian Development |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Association of Free Clinics |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Council of Behavioral Health & Family Services Provider |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Legal Assistance Foundation |
|
04/06/09
View
|
Brief of amici curiae Ohio AFL-CIO, American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees Ohio Council 8, Comunications Workers of America District 4, Fraternal Order of Police of Ohio, Incorporated, et al.
| |
Filed by: |
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees |
| |
Filed by: |
Communications Workers of America District 4 |
| |
Filed by: |
Fraternal Order of Police of Ohio, Incorporated |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio AFL-CIO |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Association of Professional Firefighters |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Association of Public School Employees (OAPSE)/AFSCME L |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Education Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Federation of Teachers |
| |
Filed by: |
Service Employees International Union District 1199 |
|
04/06/09
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae Multistate Tax Commission in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Multistate Tax Commission |
|
04/06/09
View
|
Appellant's merit brief
|
| 04/06/09
|
Supplement to brief
|
04/06/09
View
|
Brief of amici curiae Ohio Municipal League, County Commissioners Association of Ohio, Ohio Township Association, and Buckeye State Sheriffs' Association in support of appellant
| |
Filed by: |
Buckeye State Sheriffs' Association |
| |
Filed by: |
County Commissioners Association of Ohio |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Municipal League |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Township Association |
|
04/17/09
View
|
Stipulation to extension of time to file merit brief to 5/26/09
| |
Filed by: |
Carfagna's Incorporated |
| |
Filed by: |
CFZ Supermarkets, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Grocers Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Reading Food Services, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
The Sanson Company |
|
05/21/09
View
|
Motion for admission pro hac vice of Kyle O. Sollie and Sara A. Lima
| |
Filed by: |
Tyson Sales & Distribution, Inc. |
|
View
|
07/01/09: Granted
|
05/21/09
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae Tyson Sales & Distribution, Inc. in support of appellee
| |
Filed by: |
Tyson Sales & Distribution, Inc. |
|
05/26/09
View
|
Appellees' merit brief
| |
Filed by: |
Carfagna's Incorporated |
| |
Filed by: |
CFZ Supermarkets, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Grocers Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Reading Food Services, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
The Sanson Company |
|
| 05/26/09
|
Second supplement to briefs
| |
Filed by: |
Carfagna's Incorporated |
| |
Filed by: |
CFZ Supermarkets, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Grocers Association |
| |
Filed by: |
Reading Food Services, Inc. |
| |
Filed by: |
The Sanson Company |
|
05/26/09
View
|
Brief of amicus curiae The Ohio Restaurant Association in support of appellee
| |
Filed by: |
The Ohio Restaurant Association |
|
05/26/09
View
|
Appendix to brief of amicus curiae The Ohio Restaurant Association in support of appellee
| |
Filed by: |
The Ohio Restaurant Association |
|
05/26/09
View
|
Brief of amici curiae The Buckeye Institute for Public Policy Solutions and The Tax Foundation in support of appellee
| |
Filed by: |
The Buckeye Institute for Public Policy Solutions |
| |
Filed by: |
The Tax Foundation |
|
05/26/09
View
|
Motion for admission pro hac vice of Joseph D. Henchman for The Buckeye Institute for Public Policy Solutions and The Tax Foundation
| |
Filed by: |
The Buckeye Institute for Public Policy Solutions |
| |
Filed by: |
The Tax Foundation |
|
View
|
07/29/09: Granted
|
05/28/09
View
|
Stipulation to extension of time to file reply brief to 7/6/09
|
07/02/09
View
|
Reply brief
|
07/06/09
View
|
Reply brief of amicus curiae Ohio Business Roundtable
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Business Roundtable |
|
07/06/09
View
|
Reply brief of amici curiae Ohio School Boards Association et al.
| |
Filed by: |
Buckeye Association of School Administrators |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio Association of School Business Officials |
| |
Filed by: |
Ohio School Boards Association |
|
| 07/08/09
|
Oral argument scheduled for Tuesday, September 1, 2009
|
07/09/09
View
|
Notice of oral argument to be held on Tuesday, September 1, 2009
|
| 09/01/09
|
Oral argument held
|
09/17/09
View
|
DECISION: Reversed. See opinion at 2009-Ohio-4872.
|
| 10/01/09
|
Certified copy of judgment entry/mandate sent to clerk
|
| 10/26/09
|
Return of record to clerk of court/custodian
|
| 10/26/09
|
Return receipt
|