| Case No. | Case Caption | Case Status | Date
Accepted | Case Issue |
|
2020-0312
|
State of Ohio
v.
Theodis Montgomery
|
OPEN
|
4/28/2020
| Proposition of Law No. I: An Appellant is denied his right to a fair trial guaranteed by the 6th and 14th amendments to the United States constitution when a trial court permits and alleged victim to be introduced to the jury during voir dire as a representing the State of Ohio and permits them to sit with the Prosecutor for the State at counsels table throughout the entire trial in front of the jury. |
|
2020-0306
|
Motorists Mutual Insurance Company
v.
Ironics , Inc., et al. and Mercy Komar, et al.
|
OPEN
|
5/12/2020
| Proposition of Law No. 1: The incorporation of a defective ingredient into an integrated product or system does not constitute damage to “other” property for purposes of liability coverage under commercial general liability and umbrella policies. |
|
2020-0290
|
State of Ohio
v.
Sherry Tidwell
|
OPEN
|
5/12/2020
| Proposition of Law No. 1: Simple face-to-face contact between an unnamed
citizen and a police officer may be enough to remove the citizen from the
category of “anonymous” and consider him a “citizen informant,” whose tip
merits a high degree of credibility and value, rendering the tip sufficient to
withstand a Fourth Amendment challenge without independent police
corroboration. |
|
2020-0255
|
State of Ohio
v.
Robert L. Bates
|
OPEN
|
3/31/2020
| Proposition of Law I:
The failure to include a sentence of post-release control when imposing a prison sentence must be corrected on direct appeal and failure to do so precludes supervision on PRC at the end of the prison sentence. |
|
2020-0244
|
W. Randal Erickson, et al.
v.
Paul E. Morrison, et al.
|
OPEN
|
4/28/2020
| PROPOSITION OF LAW NO. I: The Marketable Title Act does not require that a
reservation set forth the name of the person holding the interest in order to be specific
and preserve the interest.
PROPOSITION OF LAW NO. 2: A property holder’s fee simple interest is preserved
under the Marketable Title Act where the party seeking relief under the Marketable
Title Act had actual knowledge of the interest. |
|
2020-0204
|
State of Ohio
v.
Tyrone Loyed
|
OPEN
(Held)
|
4/28/2020
| LAW AND ARGUMENT
Proposition of Law: The void-sentence doctrine does not require that a sentence
precisely track the statutory language set forth by statute. |
|
2020-0182
|
Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow
v.
Ohio State Board of Education et al.
|
OPEN
|
4/14/2020
| FIRST PROPOSITION OF LAW A community has a right to pursue a Chapter 119
appeal to the common pleas court from an adverse funding determination by the BOE
under R.C. 3314.08(K) |
|
2020-0152
|
Northern Frozen Foods, Inc.
v.
Ross C. Farro, et al.
|
OPEN
|
4/28/2020
| Proposition of Law 1: The doctrine of equitable estoppel may not apply to extend the fouryear
statute of limitations for the sale of goods set forth in R.C. 1302.98.
Proposition of Law 2: Statements regarding future conduct cannot meet the
misrepresentation element of the equitable estoppel doctrine to extend the four-year statute
of limitations for the sale of goods set forth in R.C. 1302.98. |
|
2020-0152
|
Northern Frozen Foods, Inc.
v.
Ross C. Farro, et al.
|
OPEN
|
4/28/2020
| NORTHERN HASEROT’S PROPOSED PROPOSITION OF
LAW: THE STATUTORY AND COMMON LAW DOCTRINE OF
PARTIAL PAYMENT APPLIES TO RESET THE STATUTE OF
LIMITATION FOR A BREACH OF CONTRACT CLAIM
GOVERNED BY SECTION 1302.98 OF THE OHIO REVISED
CODE
A. The statutory codification of the partial payment rule applies to
reset the statute of limitation on a breach of contract claim,
including those governed by Section 1302.98
ii
B. The common law doctrine of partial payment may also be applied
to the limitations period provided in Section 1302.98
C. The appellate court’s holding contradicts significant public policies
that are promoted by the partial payment doctrine |
|
2020-0143
|
State of Ohio
v.
Abdul S. Azeen
|
OPEN
|
4/14/2020
| Proposition of Law I: State v. Carpenter, 68 Ohio St.3d 59, 623 N.E.2d 66 (1993)
does not apply retroactively to pleas entered before it was decided. |
|